When Engagement Falls: Strategic Actions for CEOs and HR to Reverse the Trend

Image by Masantocreative

If employee engagement were a stock, many organizations would be nervously checking their portfolios right now. After brief post-pandemic highs, engagement levels have dipped again, and leaders everywhere are asking the same question:

Why are our people less invested, even with better tools, flexible work, and more perks than ever?

The answer isn’t mysterious. It’s measurable.

According to SHRM’s research in Employee Engagement and Commitment: A Guide to Understanding, Measuring, and Increasing Engagement in Your Organization, engagement is not about surface-level satisfaction. It’s about emotional commitment, discretionary effort, and alignment with organizational goals (SHRM, p. 3–7). When those drivers weaken, performance follows.

The good news? Engagement can be rebuilt strategically.

Let’s break it down.

1. Engagement Is Not Happiness, It’s Commitment

One of the biggest myths SHRM debunks is that engagement equals job satisfaction. It doesn’t.

Employees can be satisfied (nice office, decent coffee, predictable paycheck) and still not be engaged. Engagement is deeper; it reflects whether employees are willing to go above and beyond because they believe in the mission (SHRM, p. 5).

Why CEOs Should Care:

Engaged employees:

• Show higher productivity

• Deliver stronger customer experiences

• Stay longer

• Contribute more innovation

Disengaged employees? They do what’s required and not much else.

Real-World Example:

When Microsoft shifted toward a growth mindset culture under Satya Nadella, it focused on learning, ownership, and collaboration, not perks. Engagement improved because employees felt connected to purpose and empowered to contribute.

2. Diagnose Before You Prescribe

SHRM emphasizes that engagement must be measured intentionally, not guessed (p. 15–22). Too many organizations launch “engagement initiatives” without diagnosing root causes.

Think of it this way: If engagement drops and you respond with a pizza party, you’re prescribing candy for a broken bone.

Strategic Action for HR:

• Use structured engagement surveys.

• Combine quantitative data with qualitative feedback.

• Segment data by department, tenure, and leadership.

Actionable Tip:

Ask three simple but revealing questions:

1. Do employees understand our strategy?

2. Do they feel their work matters?

3. Do they trust leadership?

If the answers wobble, engagement will too.

3. Leadership Behavior Drives Engagement (Not HR Programs)

SHRM’s research highlights leadership as a primary driver of engagement (p. 23–30). Engagement does not cascade from hallway posters. It cascades from behavior.

Employees engage when leaders:

• Communicate clearly

• Model accountability

• Recognize contributions

• Create psychological safety

Real-World Example:

Google’s “Project Oxygen” revealed that the best managers weren’t technical geniuses; they were coaches who listened, clarified goals, and supported growth.

Translation: Engagement rises when leadership is human.

4. Align Purpose with Performance

Engagement increases when employees see a line of sight between their role and organizational success (SHRM, p. 9).

If your strategy deck is 97 slides long and your frontline staff can’t explain the mission in one sentence, you have an alignment problem.

Strategic Action:

• Simplify strategic messaging.

• Connect KPIs to impact not just output.

• Reinforce purpose in every performance review.

Actionable Tip:

Replace “Did you hit your numbers?” with“How did your work advance our mission?”

That small shift rewires engagement from compliance to contribution.

5. Make Engagement an Ongoing System, Not a Campaign

Engagement isn’t just a quarterly survey. It’s a leadership operating system.

SHRM emphasizes ongoing communication, feedback loops, and reinforcement as essential for sustaining engagement (p. 32–35).

What This Means for CEOs:

• Engagement metrics should appear in board conversations.

• Managers should be trained in engagement leadership skills.

• Recognition should be structured, not accidental.

Companies that treat engagement as infrastructure, not an initiative, outperform those that treat it like an annual morale boost.

The Cost of Doing Nothing

Disengagement doesn’t always look dramatic. It looks like:

• Slower innovation

• Quiet quitting

• Higher turnover

• Cultural fatigue

When engagement falls, performance erosion follows quietly but consistently.

And here’s the strategic reality:

Technology can optimize workflows. Compensation can attract talent. But only engagement unlocks discretionary effort.

The Leadership Reset

If engagement is declining in your organization, this is not a crisis; it’s a signal.

A signal to:

• Revisit leadership behaviors

• Strengthen strategic clarity

• Reinforce purpose

• Build trust through transparency

Because engagement isn’t about making work “fun.”It’s about making work meaningful.

Ready to Reverse the Trend?

At GladED Leadership Solutions, we help CEOs and HR executives move beyond engagement surveys to build trust-driven, capability-focused cultures that drive measurable performance.

We align purpose, leadership behavior, and organizational systems so engagement becomes embedded rather than episodic.

If you’re ready to elevate your organization to the next level and turn declining engagement into a competitive advantage, contact GladED Leadership Solutions today.

Because when engagement rises, everything else follows.